After episode 10 of harper's island, having a new theory of who the killer might be and why.... or plural now.
4 months, 2 weeks ago.
12 comments so far
Cool, I didn't know you watch Harper's Island. :) For a while it was getting boring, but the last two or three episodes have been rather good. I'd ask you about your theories, but I don't want anyone else to be spoiled...
It's a pity we can't import RSS feeds right now. If I created a Harper's Island channel, I'd import tweets from at least one cast member (the guy who plays Henry is on Twitter), and link to some news sites. Bah.
Well, what's your theory? I read some speculation that Booth may still be alive and is working with Wakefield...
until this weekend i was sure it was booth and that wakefield was dead. but nooooo. booth was the only death where body parts weren't chopped off (which would be more difficult to fake than just blood flowing down the leg). but i have started to rewatch the show beginning with episode 1 and i have to say, booth is really a klutz. it could be sully. one moment he is tough guy and the next he is a weakling. but nope, he is joe normal (henry is too much of a hero, a bit longer and more, and i will start to watch him closely and fear the worst ). my newest theory, Shea - she looks a lot like Abby's mother (wakefields love child maybe?) and there is something strange going on with her. madison is just a lonely kid amidst adults in a spooky place.
or my newest theory: there are at least two or three independant parties at work, like
1) Shea taking revenge (plus gunning for the money or out of jealousy) by copying wakefield's killings,
2) wakefield himself being angry for the imposter ruining his work (the angry artist hunting the copycat if you so will) and
3) a few unrelated accidents (like booth) spicing up the mix.
i think hanging is wakefield's modus operandi, while the the spiking/chopping is more personal, so i tend to call them on shea..... (the dad, the hubby and probably even cousin ben)
wait or could that be trish? hm. i would give katherine trish or Shea for obvious reasons. but both have an alibi, haven't they. so who? and who were the "ghosts" in the inn....
man, this is killing me!! i change my theories every other minute...... last night i had a theory, today i have lots of ideas but nothing with substance. um.
I saw on Twitter that there are two nights left for Harper's Island -- this Saturday will have a new episode, and on July 11 will be the 2-hour series finale. The actor who plays Henry tweeted back when I asked if the show is only meant to last one season and he confirmed it. He also said that almost no one gets out alive!
Since there's a bit of a gap between this week's episode and the finale, I might try to rewatch from the beginning to see if there are any clues I can pick up on. We've just been casually watching up until now, so I really don't have any theories...
the sheriff, shane and jimmy, well, the actors, are on twitter too. and H.I itself (the latter with 0 updates. my guess to protect the name)
there is something, a theory brewing in my head. still rogue and fragmented, but it will mature and make itself known when the time is right. hopefully :)
Well, since we've been watching so casually I don't even remember everyone's names. <<sheepish grin>> However, when I see theories about Shea being the killer, something just doesn't sit right. I just haven't seen anything much about her that would suggest it, but then again, I could've missed some obvious stuff. I mean, her daughter is weird, but that's all that is notable about her that I can recall... And Sully, despite acting contradictory sometimes, just doesn't seem right as the killer, either. He seems to weaselly, and too into self-preservation almost like Sarc from Alias. :) I surely hope it isn't Cal because he just seems like a nice guy.
@Adventsparky: At the beginning it was kind of ridiculous, like those cheesy horror movies that are all gore and no intelligence. But after a while it started to get more intriguing. And then up until the last 3 or so episodes, it was losing my interest again. There are a ton of characters that I really didn't care about, so their deaths were no big deal. But now that the story has gotten interesting again, it sure does seem like it's going to end with a bang. At least if you don't really like it, it's only a one-season commitment. :)
12 comments so far
Cool, I didn't know you watch Harper's Island. :) For a while it was getting boring, but the last two or three episodes have been rather good. I'd ask you about your theories, but I don't want anyone else to be spoiled...
When do we get to have private messaging here??
4 months, 2 weeks ago by jezlyn
i think we are the only ones who watch harper's island around here.... if we start a channel others will not see any messages i think
4 months, 2 weeks ago by denise
It's a pity we can't import RSS feeds right now. If I created a Harper's Island channel, I'd import tweets from at least one cast member (the guy who plays Henry is on Twitter), and link to some news sites. Bah.
Well, what's your theory? I read some speculation that Booth may still be alive and is working with Wakefield...
4 months, 2 weeks ago by jezlyn
until this weekend i was sure it was booth and that wakefield was dead. but nooooo. booth was the only death where body parts weren't chopped off (which would be more difficult to fake than just blood flowing down the leg). but i have started to rewatch the show beginning with episode 1 and i have to say, booth is really a klutz. it could be sully. one moment he is tough guy and the next he is a weakling. but nope, he is joe normal (henry is too much of a hero, a bit longer and more, and i will start to watch him closely and fear the worst ). my newest theory, Shea - she looks a lot like Abby's mother (wakefields love child maybe?) and there is something strange going on with her. madison is just a lonely kid amidst adults in a spooky place.
or my newest theory: there are at least two or three independant parties at work, like 1) Shea taking revenge (plus gunning for the money or out of jealousy) by copying wakefield's killings, 2) wakefield himself being angry for the imposter ruining his work (the angry artist hunting the copycat if you so will) and 3) a few unrelated accidents (like booth) spicing up the mix.
i think hanging is wakefield's modus operandi, while the the spiking/chopping is more personal, so i tend to call them on shea..... (the dad, the hubby and probably even cousin ben) wait or could that be trish? hm. i would give katherine trish or Shea for obvious reasons. but both have an alibi, haven't they. so who? and who were the "ghosts" in the inn....
man, this is killing me!! i change my theories every other minute...... last night i had a theory, today i have lots of ideas but nothing with substance. um.
4 months, 2 weeks ago by denise
I saw on Twitter that there are two nights left for Harper's Island -- this Saturday will have a new episode, and on July 11 will be the 2-hour series finale. The actor who plays Henry tweeted back when I asked if the show is only meant to last one season and he confirmed it. He also said that almost no one gets out alive!
Since there's a bit of a gap between this week's episode and the finale, I might try to rewatch from the beginning to see if there are any clues I can pick up on. We've just been casually watching up until now, so I really don't have any theories...
4 months, 2 weeks ago by jezlyn
the sheriff, shane and jimmy, well, the actors, are on twitter too. and H.I itself (the latter with 0 updates. my guess to protect the name)
there is something, a theory brewing in my head. still rogue and fragmented, but it will mature and make itself known when the time is right. hopefully :)
4 months, 2 weeks ago by denise
You have some time to refine your theory. :)
4 months, 2 weeks ago by jezlyn
who is it in your opionion? or if that is more how you tick, who is it not? ;-)
4 months, 2 weeks ago by denise
Well, since we've been watching so casually I don't even remember everyone's names. <<sheepish grin>> However, when I see theories about Shea being the killer, something just doesn't sit right. I just haven't seen anything much about her that would suggest it, but then again, I could've missed some obvious stuff. I mean, her daughter is weird, but that's all that is notable about her that I can recall... And Sully, despite acting contradictory sometimes, just doesn't seem right as the killer, either. He seems to weaselly, and too into self-preservation almost like Sarc from Alias. :) I surely hope it isn't Cal because he just seems like a nice guy.
4 months, 2 weeks ago by jezlyn
re-watching episodes makes a lot of my theories and suspicions crumble. old episodes are all over the net (incl. hulu and tv.com), torrents or usenet.
4 months, 2 weeks ago by denise
I have been wondering if it was any good, sounds interesting and worth a watch.
4 months, 2 weeks ago by Adventsparky
@Adventsparky: At the beginning it was kind of ridiculous, like those cheesy horror movies that are all gore and no intelligence. But after a while it started to get more intriguing. And then up until the last 3 or so episodes, it was losing my interest again. There are a ton of characters that I really didn't care about, so their deaths were no big deal. But now that the story has gotten interesting again, it sure does seem like it's going to end with a bang. At least if you don't really like it, it's only a one-season commitment. :)
4 months, 2 weeks ago by jezlyn